36

Gears 5 Review: An Excellent Sequel With a Divisive Ending

Gears 5 continues one of my favorite aspects of the Gears of War franchise: its ongoing storyline. After spending approximately 200 hours playing through the campaign and enjoying various multiplayer modes, I can confidently say that I love this game. The Coalition delivers another entertaining third-person shooter packed with familiar combat, memorable characters, and plenty of content. Yet one controversial decision near the end of the campaign left me questioning how the story should have concluded.

The fifth main installment takes the series in a more personal direction, placing Kait Diaz at the center of the story. It carries forward the events of previous games, introduces new questions about the Swarm, and expands the familiar combat formula with exploration and fresh mechanics. There is enough here to keep both returning fans and newcomers entertained, particularly those who appreciate action-heavy shooters with substantial multiplayer content.

My experience includes playing on PC and Xbox consoles, with my PC featuring an AMD Ryzen 7 5700-series processor, NVIDIA GeForce RTX 3070, and 32 GB of RAM at 1080p. Performance was enjoyable overall, though occasional stuttering and frame rate drops prevented the technical experience from feeling completely consistent.

For me, Gears 5 earns an excellent 9/10. Its campaign, combat, and multiplayer variety create a compelling package, but its divisive ending keeps it from receiving a perfect score.

Quick Verdict

Gears 5 is an excellent third-person shooter that successfully continues the franchise's storyline, offers satisfying combat, and provides plenty of ways to play. Its biggest strengths are the familiar Gears combat mechanics, campaign progression, diverse multiplayer options, and connection to earlier installments.

The storyline remains my favorite part of the experience. I enjoy seeing the events of earlier games carry forward instead of watching the franchise abandon its established history. The campaign builds upon familiar characters and conflicts, making it particularly appealing to players who have followed the series for years.

The greatest disappointment comes from the ending. Being forced to decide which character survives feels like an unnecessarily divisive way to finish an otherwise enjoyable story. I appreciate having choices in games, but this particular decision is one I would have preferred the developers to handle differently.

Occasional technical hiccups are another drawback, though they did not prevent me from enjoying the game across roughly 200 hours.

My recommendation: Fans of Gears of War, story-driven shooters, cooperative experiences, and competitive multiplayer should give Gears 5 a chance.

Gameplay and Core Mechanics

The gameplay builds upon the cover-based combat system that helped establish Gears of War as a recognizable third-person shooter franchise. Players move between defensive positions, coordinate attacks, and face enemies using an assortment of firearms, explosives, and close-range techniques.

I enjoyed the combat, weapons, campaign missions, and exploration rather than favoring one mechanic over everything else. That combination is a major reason the game held my attention for approximately 200 hours. The campaign provides a structured experience, then multiplayer offers different objectives and challenges.

Cover remains a defining mechanic. Positioning matters, aggressive attacks carry risks, and moving between defensive locations can change the outcome of an encounter. Players familiar with older Gears titles should recognize the fundamentals, making the transition into this installment fairly straightforward.

The weapon selection supports several approaches to combat. Familiar equipment such as the Lancer assault rifle and Gnasher shotgun returns alongside other firearms that suit different situations. The series' signature chainsaw bayonet remains one of its most recognizable combat features.

The game's Jack companion brings another dimension to the campaign. Jack can assist players with support abilities, environmental interactions, and combat-related upgrades. These mechanics give the campaign more variety than a sequence of standard firefights alone.

Playing on medium difficulty provided the basis for my campaign experience. I completed the story at that setting, so my assessment reflects a moderate challenge rather than the game's highest difficulty options.

Gears 5 Gameplay Highlights

Several gameplay elements contribute to my positive opinion of Gears 5. I particularly appreciate the combination of combat encounters, campaign exploration, and weapon variety. Each gives players another reason to remain engaged beyond advancing the storyline.

The campaign features sections with broader exploration opportunities than the traditional corridor-based structure associated with earlier installments. Areas such as the icy region of North Tyrus and the red deserts of Vasgar introduce the Skiff, allowing players to travel between objectives and discover optional activities.

These locations represent an interesting departure from the series' familiar approach. They offer a different rhythm between battles, opening up opportunities to explore before returning to the more recognizable combat encounters.

The multiplayer selection deserves recognition, too. I spent time across a mixture of modes rather than concentrating exclusively on one competitive playlist. Switching between different types of gameplay helped contribute to the game's longevity.

Multiplayer Modes and Variety

Gears 5 includes several multiplayer experiences built around different objectives. The selection provides distinct activities for players interested in competitive matches, cooperative survival, or objective-driven missions.

Versus focuses on competitive combat against other players. Its playlists support different match structures, ranging from traditional team battles to modes with additional objectives.

Horde places a cooperative team against increasingly challenging waves of enemies. Players can select classes, develop abilities, establish defenses, and cooperate to survive.

Escape offers a different cooperative structure. Players enter hostile Swarm hives, battle through enemy encounters, and attempt to escape before the mission becomes impossible.

The availability of these modes creates more variety than a campaign-only shooter could offer. For players who enjoy moving between competitive matches and cooperative activities, the selection adds considerable long-term appeal.

Graphics and Visual Design

The graphics in Gears 5 are good overall. The Coalition maintains the recognizable visual identity of Gears of War through detailed character models, large industrial environments, distinctive enemies, and intense combat effects.

The campaign introduces environmental variety that contrasts with the franchise's traditionally grim urban battlefields. Frozen terrain, desert environments, and damaged settlements help distinguish different chapters of the story.

Character designs retain the heavy armor and recognizable silhouettes associated with Gears. The visual presentation reinforces the series' military science-fiction identity without abandoning its established style.

Combat animations and weapon effects contribute to the action-oriented presentation. The game's familiar execution systems, environmental destruction, and enemy designs complement its aggressive combat mechanics.

On PC, Gears 5 supports a considerable range of graphical adjustments, including texture quality, shadows, environmental detail, and field-of-view options. These settings give players flexibility when balancing visual fidelity against performance.

My overall impression of the graphical presentation is positive. I would rate it below the very best aspect of the game, which remains its storyline, but the visuals support the experience effectively.

Story, Characters, and Worldbuilding

The story is the primary reason I love Gears 5. Instead of abandoning the events of previous installments, the game continues the established conflict and develops mysteries introduced earlier in the franchise.

Kait Diaz becomes the central protagonist, taking a more prominent position after her introduction in Gears of War 4. Her mysterious connection to the Swarm creates a personal conflict that drives much of the campaign.

Familiar characters return, including Marcus Fenix, JD Fenix, and Del Walker. Their involvement helps maintain continuity with earlier games and gives longtime players recognizable connections to the established storyline.

I particularly appreciate this continuity. The relationships, past conflicts, and ongoing war matter more when a sequel acknowledges what happened before it. Following the storyline across multiple installments is a major part of the attraction for me.

The game explores Kait's history alongside the broader struggle for humanity's survival. Its focus on her background changes the perspective of the campaign without abandoning the larger Gears narrative.

The Ending Is My Biggest Complaint

Minor spoiler warning: This section discusses a major decision near the campaign's conclusion without revealing the outcome of either option.

My biggest criticism concerns the decision players must make near the end of Gears 5. The campaign forces you to choose which of two important characters survives.

I understand the intention behind a difficult narrative decision. A choice involving established characters can create emotional consequences and make players feel responsible for the outcome. Still, I did not enjoy being placed in that position.

The Gears franchise has always included major losses, dangerous situations, and difficult moments. In previous installments, those events formed part of a story presented by the developers. Here, the responsibility for a significant character's survival falls on the player.

That approach did not work particularly well for me. I would have preferred a fixed narrative outcome that could carry directly into future installments without requiring the story to account for two different possibilities.

This criticism does not erase my appreciation for the campaign. I still love the story and its connection to earlier games, but the ending remains the one decision I would change.

Audio and Sound Design

The audio presentation in Gears 5 is good overall. Character dialogue, weapon effects, environmental sounds, and musical compositions contribute to the game's recognizable atmosphere.

The franchise has always placed considerable attention on the sounds of its weapons. The Lancer, Gnasher, and other firearms have distinct audio identities that help reinforce the feel of combat.

Voice acting remains an important part of the presentation, particularly in a campaign featuring returning characters and emotionally significant events. Conversations help communicate relationships and develop the larger conflict.

The soundtrack, composed by Ramin Djawadi, supports the game's military science-fiction setting. Its dramatic compositions complement the campaign's action sequences and narrative moments.

My opinion of the graphics, voice acting, and soundtrack is positive across the board. None of these areas stands out as a major disappointment, though I consider the narrative continuity and gameplay more compelling reasons to recommend the game.

Performance and Technical Stability

My technical experience with Gears 5 was enjoyable overall, but it was not completely free from problems.

I played on PC and Xbox consoles. My documented PC configuration for this review included the following hardware:

During gameplay, I encountered occasional stuttering and FPS drops. These issues were frustrating at times, particularly for a shooter where responsive combat and smooth motion contribute significantly to the experience.

The interruptions were not frequent enough to change my favorable overall opinion. My playtime reached approximately 200 hours, and I completed the campaign.

I did not record controlled benchmark results for this review, so I cannot provide verified average frame rates, minimum FPS measurements, or comparisons between individual console models.

PC Graphics Options

One advantage of the PC release is its selection of graphics settings. Players can adjust texture detail, shadows, resolution scaling, field of view, and other options to match their hardware.

The game includes a built-in benchmarking utility for evaluating performance under selected settings. This gives PC players a practical method of testing graphical changes instead of relying entirely on guesswork.

My occasional stuttering and frame rate drops remain a legitimate criticism, but I cannot attribute them to a particular setting, driver, or game update without additional testing.

Performance verdict: Good overall, with occasional interruptions that keep the technical experience from receiving a higher score.

What the Game Gets Right

A Story That Respects Earlier Installments

My favorite strength is the continuation of the established Gears storyline. Returning characters, unresolved conflicts, and Kait's central role give the campaign a meaningful connection to earlier games.

This continuity makes Gears 5 particularly attractive to established fans. Those who have followed the series can appreciate the relationships and developments that build upon previous installments.

Familiar and Enjoyable Combat

The game's cover-based shooting remains recognizable. Weapons, positioning, aggressive attacks, and squad-based encounters maintain the series' action-focused identity.

I enjoyed the combination of these mechanics rather than finding one dominant feature responsible for the entire experience.

Plenty of Multiplayer Variety

Horde, Versus, and Escape provide different ways to enjoy the combat system. Players interested in cooperative survival can select Horde, competitive players have Versus, and Escape offers shorter objective-driven cooperative missions.

This variety is particularly useful for people who enjoy multiplayer but prefer changing activities instead of repeating one playlist indefinitely.

Strong Long-Term Entertainment

Reaching approximately 200 hours is a meaningful indication of how much time I chose to spend with the game.

The completed campaign and mixture of multiplayer modes provided enough content to maintain my interest. That combination contributes strongly to my assessment of its value.

Where the Game Falls Short

A Forced Narrative Decision

The most significant weakness is the final survival choice. I dislike having to decide which important character lives, particularly in a franchise built around a continuing storyline.

A decision with such serious consequences changes how players experience the conclusion. For me, it detracted from an otherwise enjoyable campaign.

Occasional Stuttering and Frame Rate Drops

The technical issues were another frustration. Occasional stutters or drops in frame rate can interrupt the flow of combat, particularly when movement and aiming require consistent responsiveness.

These interruptions did not ruin my experience, but they deserve consideration from players sensitive to uneven performance.

Exploration Changes the Traditional Campaign Rhythm

The broader exploration sections represent a change from the more linear approach of earlier Gears games. Some players may appreciate the additional freedom, particularly the opportunity to visit optional locations.

Others who favor continuous combat may prefer the older campaign structure. This is a design trade-off rather than a major personal complaint.

Value, Content, and Replayability

When evaluating a game's value, I consider how much entertainment it provides rather than judging it solely by its purchase price.

With approximately 200 hours invested in Gears 5, I received substantial entertainment from the available content. Completing the campaign and spending time across several multiplayer modes gave me reasons to continue playing.

The campaign offers a story that connects to the larger franchise, giving returning players an opportunity to revisit its events. Cooperative campaign support provides another option for players interested in experiencing the story with friends.

Horde, Versus, and Escape significantly extend the amount of available content. Their different objectives, progression systems, and cooperative or competitive structures add variety beyond the campaign.

The game features character classes, cosmetic rewards, and progression systems within its multiplayer components. These can provide further goals for players interested in developing their characters or collecting rewards.

Pricing changes across storefronts and sales, so I would not assign a current purchase value using an unverified price. Based on the amount of time I spent playing, I consider Gears 5 an excellent entertainment value.

Value verdict: The combination of campaign content and multiplayer variety makes the game worth recommending, particularly for players interested in spending substantial time with the franchise.

Comparisons With Similar Games

Gears of War 4

Gears of War 4 provides the most direct comparison. It introduces Kait, JD, and Del, establishes the renewed Swarm threat, and lays the groundwork for the events of Gears 5.

The fifth installment expands that storyline, changes the central protagonist, and introduces broader campaign environments. Its emphasis on Kait's history gives the narrative a different focus from its predecessor.

My preference for continuing storylines makes this connection particularly valuable.

Earlier Gears of War Games

The original Gears titles established the franchise's cover-based shooting, brutal close-range combat, cooperative campaigns, and character relationships.

Gears 5 retains these foundations but experiments with additional exploration and support mechanics. The result is a sequel that shares many recognizable features with its predecessors without following their exact campaign structure.

For longtime fans, the continuing story offers a reason to remain invested in the franchise.

Other Third-Person Shooters

Players familiar with titles such as The Division 2 or Outriders will recognize certain broad similarities, including third-person shooting and cooperative combat.

The underlying systems differ considerably. The Division 2 places stronger focus on loot and character builds, and Outriders features ability-driven combat and equipment progression.

Gears 5 remains more closely associated with structured cover combat, cinematic storytelling, and its established multiplayer modes.

Pros and Cons

Pros

• Excellent continuation of the established Gears of War storyline.
• Enjoyable cover-based shooting, combat mechanics, and weapon selection.
• Engaging campaign with returning characters and expanded environments.
• Multiple multiplayer experiences, including Horde, Versus, and Escape.
• Good graphics, voice acting, and soundtrack.
• Excellent long-term entertainment value, supported by my 200 hours of playtime.

Cons

• The forced survival choice near the end of the campaign is disappointing.
• Occasional stuttering interrupts otherwise enjoyable gameplay.
• Frame rate drops affect technical consistency.
• Broader exploration sections may not appeal to players who prefer traditional linear Gears campaigns.

Final Verdict

Gears 5 is an excellent addition to the Gears of War franchise. Its familiar combat, continuing storyline, multiplayer variety, and strong presentation make it a game I thoroughly enjoyed across approximately 200 hours.

The storyline remains my favorite part. I appreciate watching established characters and conflicts develop across multiple games, and this installment provides another substantial chapter in that ongoing narrative.

My biggest disappointment is the ending. Being forced to choose which character survives is a decision I would have preferred the developers to handle through a fixed storyline. The occasional stuttering and FPS drops are smaller criticisms that affect the technical experience.

Still, those shortcomings do not outweigh everything I enjoyed. Between the campaign and multiplayer content, Gears 5 provides more than enough entertainment to justify a strong recommendation.

Whether you're returning to the franchise or interested in trying a third-person shooter with cooperative and competitive options, Gears 5 deserves consideration.

Final Score: 9/10 – Excellent

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Gears 5 worth playing in 2024?

Yes. Based on my experience through June 19, 2024, Gears 5 offers an enjoyable campaign, familiar third-person shooting, and several multiplayer modes. After approximately 200 hours, I consider it an excellent game.

Can you play Gears 5 without playing previous Gears of War games?

Yes, but playing Gears of War 4 first provides valuable context for Kait Diaz, JD Fenix, Del Walker, and the Swarm. Earlier installments provide further background on the franchise's history and returning characters.

Does Gears 5 have multiplayer and cooperative gameplay?

Yes. The game features competitive Versus multiplayer, cooperative Horde and Escape modes, and campaign co-op for up to three players. Each mode provides a different type of experience.

Does Gears 5 run well on PC?

The PC release includes extensive graphics customization and a built-in benchmarking utility. On my Ryzen 7 5700-series and RTX 3070 configuration at 1080p, I encountered occasional stuttering and FPS drops. My overall experience remained enjoyable.

Is the Gears 5 ending controversial?

The campaign features a major survival decision near its conclusion. I personally disliked being forced to make that choice, particularly after following the franchise's continuing storyline. Other players may appreciate the dramatic consequences, but I would have preferred a fixed conclusion.

---

CyberD3m0n
From Pixels to Purpose
Gaming isn't just what I do, it's who I am. Every challenge, every quest, every pixel has shaped my journey.

I’m CyberD3m0n, a passionate gamer and live streamer who thrives on challenges and connection. Join me for epic gameplay, insightful reviews, and a fun journey as we conquer new adventures together!

📺 Stream With Me:
YouTube | Twitch | Kick | Rumble

🌐 Socials:
BlueSky | Mastodon | Facebook

🎮 Main Hub:
cyberd3m0nstream